Mohsin Naqvi Rejects BCCI Request for Asia Cup Trophy

The Asia Cup 2025 may have concluded weeks ago, but the tournament refuses to fade from the spotlight. Instead of being remembered only for India’s on-field success, it has become a stage for fresh political and sporting tensions between arch-rivals Pakistan and India. The controversy reached new heights this week when Asian Cricket Council (ACC) Chairman Mohsin Naqvi firmly rejected the Board of Control for Cricket in India’s (BCCI) demand to hand over the trophy.

The Ceremony Controversy

India may have won the Asia Cup final, but the victory ceremony took a shocking turn. When Mohsin Naqvi, who also serves as Chairman of the Pakistan Cricket Board (PCB), stepped forward to present the trophy, Indian players refused to accept it. In an extraordinary and unprecedented move, Naqvi ordered that the trophy be removed from the stage, leaving the champions empty-handed.

The decision stunned cricket fans across the world. For the first time in the history of major ICC or ACC events, the winning team left without lifting the silverware. Cricket analysts described the incident as “unthinkable” and “deeply damaging” for the spirit of the game.

Heated Exchange at the ACC Meeting

The issue returned during the latest ACC executive meeting, where Indian representatives, led by BCCI Vice-President Rajeev Shukla, demanded that the trophy be officially delivered to India. According to sources, Mohsin Naqvi dismissed the request, saying the matter was not part of the official agenda. In a sharp remark, he suggested that if India truly wanted the trophy, the Indian captain should personally travel to ACC headquarters to collect it.

This comment reportedly infuriated the Indian side, who were participating virtually. Tensions escalated further when BCCI officials proposed sending the trophy directly to the International Cricket Council (ICC) in Dubai. The discussion grew heated until other ACC members intervened to calm the situation. Even so, Indian representatives abruptly logged out of the meeting, signaling their displeasure.

A Tournament Marred by Controversies

The trophy row is only the latest in a long list of controversies surrounding the 2025 Asia Cup. From the very start, political undertones overshadowed the cricket. Reports of Indian players refusing to shake hands with Pakistani counterparts, complaints over scheduling, and symbolic gestures made during matches all fueled tensions.

By the time the final was played, the rivalry had spilled far beyond the cricket pitch. The refusal to accept the trophy was seen by many as a political act, further straining already fragile sporting relations between the two nations.

Historical Background of Rivalries

Pakistan and India share one of the fiercest rivalries in world sport, with cricket often serving as a mirror of their political relationship. Previous tournaments have also witnessed disputes. In 2018, scheduling disagreements nearly derailed the Asia Cup, while in 2023, security concerns forced matches to be relocated. Each time, the rivalry between the two boards — PCB and BCCI — has made headlines as much as the matches themselves.

The 2025 Asia Cup controversy, however, is unique because it has created a direct conflict over the tournament’s most symbolic prize: the trophy itself.

What Happens Next?

For now, the Asia Cup trophy remains in the custody of the ACC. Officials have not announced any plan to deliver it to India, and there are growing doubts about whether the matter will be resolved quietly. Analysts believe the dispute could resurface in upcoming ICC meetings, especially with the Champions Trophy 2025 scheduled to take place in Pakistan early next year.

Sports experts warn that the standoff reflects a larger problem: cricket’s inability to stay free from political influence. “The Asia Cup should have celebrated cricketing excellence, but instead it has become a battlefield of pride and politics,” one commentator noted.

Impact on Fans and the Spirit of the Game

For millions of fans, the Asia Cup is more than just a tournament; it is a celebration of Asian cricket. This year, however, the controversies overshadowed the performances of players on the field. Many fear that such disputes damage the credibility of the sport and take away from the joy of the game.

Social media remains divided. While some Indian fans support their team’s stance, many others argue that refusing the trophy disrespects the spirit of cricket. Pakistani fans, on the other hand, see Naqvi’s strong response as a show of authority, claiming that the BCCI often tries to dominate Asian cricket politics.

The Bigger Picture

As of now, the Asia Cup 2025 will be remembered not only for India’s victory but also for the political drama that followed. The fate of the trophy remains uncertain, symbolizing how unresolved tensions continue to define Pakistan–India cricket.

The incident highlights a larger truth: when these two nations meet, cricket is never just a game. It becomes a reflection of pride, politics, and power — and the trophy standoff is only the latest example of how far the rivalry extends beyond the boundary ropes.

READ MORE: ILT20 Makes History with First-Ever Auction: Pakistan Stars in Spotlight